迈克尔杰克逊的MV who is it 没看懂

百度完还是没看懂

Who Is It （Michael Jackson / Dangerous）

导演：David Fincher
拍摄地点及时间：1992，一部分在Neverland
首映日期：1992

简评：该音乐录影有两个版本。一个是Michael历年的音乐录影中的精华镜头的集锦。另一个版本则讲述了心情郁闷的Michael发现自己的女朋友是个从一个指定场所奔赴另一个客户点的高级妓女的故事。他前往女友的公寓，发现那里凌乱不堪，而他照片则被撕碎在地。彻底失望的他毅然决定离开女友登上飞机远离伤心地。值得一提的是，尽管导演是大名鼎鼎的大卫·芬奇，但他却从一开始就和Michael在创作理念上发生了分歧。最终，Michael
Jackson只在该片中短暂出镜，其余镜头均是由他的模仿者E'Casanova饰演

墓碑下的吻 发表于 2006-6-15 13:51

我对“WHO IS IT”MV的个人理解！

    首先，我是非常喜欢MJ的这首MV，整个故事表达了城市里人与人的那种冷漠和担当着不同的角色在故事里的心理挣扎！从最低层的（性工作者，就是那个女主角）到管理者（就是那个带眼镜的家伙和那个年纪稍大的女人）再到二把手（也就是那个有胡子象管家和保镖的）还有就是最高层（MJ）。

    再讲是整个MV都带一种无形的力量和渲染力去震撼着每个观众，去表达导演对现今社会有另一种自己的观点和内心的批判！每个人都把其他人看成是一件可以利用的“工具”，每个人都想利用这些“工具”达到自己的目的，这就是我对歌名中的“IT”的看法，而且每个人都漠视这些自己正在利用的“工具”！我想这也就是导演对歌名的理解和向观众讲故事的表达方式！

    好了，接着是讲讲我对MV的个人理解！在前面我已分析过MV里每个角色的身份和角色之间的关系架构，故事是讲述一个国际高级的性服务组织，为他们的客户量身定做提供性服务！去迎合每个不同口味的客户，所以我们在MV中可以看到女主角在不停的换装，不停地更换形象。不停地在不同地点去找那些富豪，其中坐轮椅的那个家伙其实是可以走路的，大家仔细再看看有一个镜头他自己拔开氧气罩要站起走到床边，而那个稍大年纪的女人就是管理那些沦落的女孩子，有很多镜头都有交代她再控制和监管着那群女孩子，还有就是那个带眼镜的那个家伙是负责向那些富豪们收去费用和联系那些客户的，有镜头就是交代他把收回来的一箱箱的美金装上车和清点美金的数量。而那个有胡子的老家伙是MJ的助手和管家，负责处理组织的问题，好象当女主角去到MJ的家门，其实我想导演是想交代女主角想摆脱这个组织去找MJ帮忙！但被管家拒于门外。然后被两个黑手（带眼镜的和那个老女人）发现了，还打了女主角一个耳光！

    而在MV里有两样很主要的点，一就是金名片，二就是那张总是不时出现的脸和床上躲在床单下的那些隐形人，金明片是代表每次去为那些富豪服务的女孩子不同的身份不同的名字，而MJ拿着的其中一张名片可能是代表着MJ对其中一个女孩有着一份特殊的感情和关系，在后来那个管家把一叠金名片扔出门外给女主角，可能是提醒女主角她还有这么多的身份。而另一点就是那张脸,我的理解是表现每个角色的内心挣扎，特别是MJ的内心世界，因为其实在MV里MJ根本不想再这样进行下去，MJ所表演的角色身心都很累（就象被那些小报乱写的心情一样），是一种无形而又存在的一种挣扎和压力，MJ的表演非常出色！！！而导演用这种表现方式也体现了导演的功力和风格，使到整个MV充满了张力和感染力！！！非常到位！！！导演在MV里每个细节都考虑的非常仔细，非常的巧妙和周全！！！恰到好处!!!很多的表达都是在不经意地打动观众，震撼观众！！！就象MJ在上飞机是在机场地面就有一个MJ的LOGO！！！非常COOL！！！还有到最后一个镜头，MJ双手放后站在一个大型露台，好象就暗示MJ为了逃离那个充满压抑和令到MJ身心疲惫的世界，去到了一个十分安静的一个环境去沉思这个疯狂的世界和每个出现在他旁边的那一张张丑恶的脸孔！！！究竟是什么？？？究竟是谁？？？究竟谁是它？？？它有是谁？？？WHO IS IT？？？

这部MV的含义非常深刻，是暗指一些想要千方百计接近男主角的人，如何挖空心思地上门找男主角，并且，还用欺骗的手段，诱使男主角就犯，那些金属片都是想要接近他的人的名片，其实，这么多张名片，都说的是同一个人，实际上没有几个女的，只有一个女人，她负责扮演接近男主角，并迫使男主角不得不总是对同一个人付帐，扇了巴掌，是那个妓女的幕后指使，觉得她没有完成任务，就打了她耳光。不知楼上对我的理解满意吗？实际上这部MV也暗指迈迈的哥哥的女友，想要转而接近迈迈是所做出的某些伎俩。

其中坐轮椅的那个家伙其实是可以走路的，大家仔细再看看有一个镜头他自己拔开氧气罩要站起走到床边，

这是为了表现女主角的魅力吧…… 意思是连双脚残废的人见到女主也情不自禁啊……

才知道是david fincher导的,怪不得俺这么多年也一直看不懂~

The music video for "Who Is It" was directed by David Fincher (Alien 3, Panic Room, Fight Club and Se7en). The video is set in a neo-chrome Blade Runner-like landscape, where surfaces reflect light and denote luxury in all its splendor. We see Michael Jackson as a suffering recluse who has come to the conclusion that his girlfriend is cheating. He finds a platinum business card with the name 'Alex' seemingly confirming that she is cheating with the person whose name is on the card. As the video progresses, we learn that the girlfriend is working for a secret exclusive billionaire-boys-club escort agency. Her identity and visual appearance is changed regularly, usually between clients, and is confirmed by the platinum business cards she presents to each client as the night goes on. This reveals that the name 'Alex' on the card found by Jackson is one of her aliases and is not a secret lover. When she senses that something is wrong and defies her watchers to run back to Jackson's home to find him. She finds Jackson's assistant at the door, who refuses to let her in and reveals that Jackson has left and probably for good. The assistant then hands her a collection of her alias business cards revealing that her secret is out and that she has been exposed. Devastated, she is forced to return submissively back to her ruthless employees and continue on as a high class prostitute. The video ends with the ex-girlfriend being prepared for another client while Jackson attempts to sleep on a jet. Throughout the video, a strange ghostly face appears in Jackson's surroundings -- the appearances seem to coincide with Jackson's despair.

In the United States, the music video was never aired on MTV or VH-1. Instead, the video was replaced with montage footage of various music videos by Jackson, as well as live performances during the Bad tour and Motown 25.

英文解释
译： 英语 (自动检测) » 中文
The music video for "Who Is It" was directed by David Fincher (Alien 3, Panic Room, Fight Club and Se7en). The video is set in a neo-chrome Blade Runner-like landscape, where surfaces reflect light and denote luxury in all its splendor. We see Michael Jackson as a suffering recluse who has come to the conclusion that his girlfriend is cheating. He finds a platinum business card with the name 'Alex' seemingly confirming that she is cheating with the person whose name is on the card. As the video progresses, we learn that the girlfriend is working for a secret exclusive billionaire-boys-club escort agency. Her identity and visual appearance is changed regularly, usually between clients, and is confirmed by the platinum business cards she presents to each client as the night goes on. This reveals that the name 'Alex' on the card found by Jackson is one of her aliases and is not a secret lover. When she senses that something is wrong and defies her watchers to run back to Jackson's home to find him. She finds Jackson's assistant at the door, who refuses to let her in and reveals that Jackson has left and probably for good. The assistant then hands her a collection of her alias business cards revealing that her secret is out and that she has been exposed. Devastated, she is forced to return submissively back to her ruthless employees and continue on as a high class prostitute. The video ends with the ex-girlfriend being prepared for another client while Jackson attempts to sleep on a jet. Throughout the video, a strange ghostly face appears in Jackson's surroundings -- the appearances seem to coincide with Jackson's despair.

In the United States, the music video was never aired on MTV or VH-1. Instead, the video was replaced with montage footage of various music videos by Jackson, as well as live performances during the Bad tour and Motown 25.    对于“是谁”音乐录影带的导演是大卫芬奇（异形3，惊恐室，搏击俱乐部和Se7en）。录像是在一个新成立铬银翼杀手样加工，如表面反射光，并在其所有记为辉煌的奢侈品。我们认为这是一个痛苦的隐士谁得出的结论是，他的女朋友是欺骗迈克尔杰克逊。他发现一个名为'亚历克斯'似乎证实，她与名列作弊卡铂名片。随着影片的进展，我们知道，女朋友是亿万富翁的独家秘密工作男孩俱乐部护送机构。她的身份和外观就是定期更换，通常与客户，并得到白金名片她提交的每一个客户作为夜间的推移确认。这表明这个名字'亚历克斯'上的卡杰克逊发现是她的一个别名，而不是一个秘密情人。当她感觉有些不对劲，并公然违抗她的观察家运行回到杰克逊的家中找到他。她发现在门口杰克逊的助手，谁拒绝让她并透露，杰克逊已经离开和良好的可能。当时的助理，她的手，她的别名名片集合透露，她的秘密是出来，她已暴露无遗。破坏，她被迫回到乖乖回到她无情的雇员，并继续作为一个高级妓女。这部最终被另一位客户准备的同时杰克逊试图睡在飞机的前女友。在整个视频，一个奇怪的幽灵般出现在杰克逊面临的环境-在外表看来，以配合杰克逊的绝望。

在美国，音乐录像从未播出的MTV和VH - 1等。相反，这段录像是取代各种音乐视频剪辑片段由杰克逊，以及在坏的旅游和汽车城25个现场表演。