我觉得好看，比变2和tdk都好看

TDK看了没感觉
第九区后半段还可以
前半段还是有点闷
不是很喜欢这种拍摄手法

拍摄手法不错，但剧情薄弱，人物傻兮兮的，最后的感人气氛也做得不好，另外就是不要和变形金刚这种无剧情效果片比。

续集难道是3年后外星人回来拍飞地球人么

有点像去年tdk的情况 不过还是tdk要热很多 个人更喜欢tdk

我也感觉这片一般

TDK虽然我也觉得没那么神，和这部比起来要高很多了

09年和UP并称神作的片子了

以上为个人观点

硬是要拿这么部非硬科幻的电影来考据挑刺，实在是件很蛋疼的事

不过，满足你们


Is "District 9" based on a book?  
No. District 9 is an expansion of the 2005 short film Alive in Joburg. The short was adapted for District 9 by South African-born director Neill Blomkamp and screenwriter Terri Tatchell.  
《第九区》是否是根据小说改编的？
不是。《第九区》是2005年短片《约翰内斯堡的外星人》的加长版。《第九区》由南非裔导演Neill Blomkamp和剧作家Terri Tatchell改编自该短片。

How do the humans and aliens understand each other?  
The aliens had been on Earth for 28 years, more than enough time to learn each others' languages.  
人类和外星人是如何沟通的？
外星人已经在地球呆了28年了，已经有足够的时间来学习彼此的语言。

Why did the aliens not retaliate against the oppression from mankind?  
Although many aliens participated in riots and general upheaval, it is assumed from the documentary portion of the film that there was no actual alien-led attempt at fighting back and gaining freedom from the humans until Christopher Johnson and Wikus Van De Merwe (Sharlto Copley) teamed up. There are several reasons for this. At the beginning of the film, it is mentioned that the aliens aboard the mothership were mostly "worker" aliens. Without a leader, they didn't know what to do and were basically brutish. They were also found malnourished and very sick, and so they were in a vulnerable situation where it would be very easy to take their weapons from them. The few that were able to smuggle their weapons into their new homes had to be very secretive about them and were probably waiting for a better moment to strike.  
为什么外星人不向人类的压迫发起反抗？
虽然许多外星人都参加了暴（*）动和动（*）乱，但是根据纪录片部分看来，在Christopher Johnson（外星人）和Wikus Van De Merwe（男猪脚）合作之前，都没有外星人领导发起过任何回击以获得自由。原因有几个。在电影开头，有提到在主体飞船上的外星人大部分都是“工人阶级”。没有领导人，他们不知道该怎么办，只是生性野蛮。同时人类发现这些外星人营养不良体质虚弱，所以它们一直处于弱势，人类很容易就可以没收它们的武器。少数可以将武器带入新家的外星人都是偷偷摸摸的，它们可能在等待一个绝佳的时机发起反抗。


  


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2 《第九区》的一些疑问和解答，来自IMDb。  

Why did the humans let the Prawns bring all their weapons down, including the Mech suit?  
It's made clear in the movie that the aliens have no way back up to the ship, and they only came down with the assistance of the humans. Therefore there's the obvious question of why the aliens have so many weapons in the slums. The movie does not address this. Some options:
为什么人类允许虾人带它们的武器下来，包括铁皮机器人？
电影已经说得很清楚外星人无法再回到主体飞船上，是人类协助它们撤离出飞船的。因此，有一个明显的问题就是为什么在贫民窟的外星人会拥有那么多武器。电影并没有解释这个问题。一些观点：

1) The weapons are taken from the ship by aliens when evacuated, and are not confiscated. Plausiblity depends on who is responsible for the evacuation, how organised the evacuation is, and how obvious it is that the items are weapons (e.g. stowed/unstowed).
1. 在撤离主体飞船的时侯，武器由外星人带下船，并且没有被没收。这要看是谁负责撤离行动的，如何组织撤离的，以及这些物品看起来有多像武器（比如是否填装弹药和未填装弹药）。

2) The weapons are taken from the ship by humans at any time, or are confiscated from the aliens by humans during the evacuation, but wind up back with the aliens somehow. Plausibility depends on who holds the weapons, when the weapons are stolen, who steals the weapons and why, and how the weapons are passed back to the aliens.
2. 武器是由人类在某个时候带下飞船的，或者在撤离时从外星人手中没收而来，但是不知何种原因又辗转回到了外星人手中。这要看是谁得到了武器，武器什么时候被偷的，谁偷了武器而且为什么要偷，以及武器是怎样回到外星人手里的。

3) The weapons arrived on the dropship. Plausibility depends on the number and type of weapons. Certainly there was room for no more than a few of the Mech suits in the dropship.
3. 武器是由落下的飞船带下来的。这要看武器的数量和类型。可以肯定的是小飞船只能搭载几个铁皮机器人而已。

It is especially significant that the above reasons depend on the amount of physical exertion, wit and drive required of the aliens, who were extremely apathetic, malnourished, and exhausted upon arrival.  
非常重要的是上述原因的合理性依赖于外星人所需的体能负荷、智慧和动力，它们在刚到时极其漠然、营养不良并且已经筋疲力尽。

[ 本帖最后由 九十九●忍 于 2009-9-9 13:28 编辑 ]

这片拍续集10有89是渣。。

这片子真正让我觉得爽的时候是懦弱无能的男主角在听到恢复人类需要3年后猛K大虾爸爸，然后欺骗小虾开飞船逃跑被击落这一段，感觉很自然，尤其是大虾的表情。

披着科幻片外衣的伦理片！
看完后，很让人回味！

认为是本年度目前来说最好的片子。没有之一。远超变2。

[posted by wap, platform: Nokia (E71)]

不要以为在tg的战区脑补这个词是贬义的，就到哪里都是贬义的了。有多少天朝电影和番帮电影被毙掉是因为广电总局的脑补？人家要怎么脑补你还真是很难管的到

这是披着假科幻外皮的变形记呀

电脑上看的，先看的旅行到宇宙尽头，睡着n次，接着看d9，全片没打一个哈欠，最后太惨烈了，主角的机架在趴下后再站起来是那微颤的双腿给人感觉里面坐的人也已经到了极限的。我觉得主角不是为了外星人起义，我觉得是受气受到了极限，突然爆发了，顺带上照顾红背心外星人而已（毕竟之前扁过人家，人家好歹也和他一起战斗过）